indiTraders - Forum for the Active Indian Trader

indiTraders - Forum for the Active Indian Trader (http://www.inditraders.com/index.php)
-   Amibroker (http://www.inditraders.com/amibroker/)
-   -   KBrain (http://www.inditraders.com/amibroker/1014-kbrain.html)

cas67 16-06-2009 10:08 AM

KBrain
 
1 Attachment(s)
Hello all,
please check this
http://stocktechnician.blogspot.com/ [ Kbrain - formula for amibroker] this new formula looks superb.....Karthik sir Thank you very much and hats off , you are only one from whom i see new concepts of indicators/traing system..
Thank you

uasish 16-06-2009 10:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cas67 (Post 18723)
Hello all,
please check this
http://stocktechnician.blogspot.com/ [ Kbrain - formula for amibroker] this new formula looks superb.....Karthik sir Thank you very much and hats off , you are only one from whom i see new concepts of indicators/traing system..
Thank you

As usual Karthik is always to help other traders.:risehat:

Renu 16-06-2009 10:37 AM

so finally it has come out!!!

thanks...

and what about HAS system!!!

Ajax i4u 16-06-2009 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kingfisher (Post 18729)
so finally it has come out!!!

thanks...

and what about HAS system!!!

Me too want to learn :risehat:

bimbo 16-06-2009 07:18 PM

Thankyou very much Karthik,Had been looking for Brain Trading system since a Long time

bimbo 16-06-2009 07:37 PM

The SAR Line not apeearing
 
Karthik,The SAR line is not appearing on my chart.See the Attachment.What may be the reason ?

anand 16-06-2009 08:16 PM

right click on the chart and go to parameters and choose yes to stopline

:cheers:

karthikmarar 16-06-2009 08:30 PM

A small point regarding the Kbrain Bar colors. Green indicates up moves, Red down moves and blue sideways.

anand 16-06-2009 09:28 PM

i am not able to backtest it
am i missing anything
thank u karthick

Rajadhiraj 16-06-2009 09:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cas67 (Post 18723)
Hello all,
please check this
http://stocktechnician.blogspot.com/ [ Kbrain - formula for amibroker] this new formula looks superb.....Karthik sir Thank you very much and hats off , you are only one from whom i see new concepts of indicators/traing system..
Thank you

Thanks looks great


Quote:

Originally Posted by karthikmarar (Post 18960)
A small point regarding the Kbrain Bar colors. Green indicates up moves, Red down moves and blue sideways.

My version comes with lime for upbars not green :)

The AFL plots the chart, colored bars Dots and Stop line nicely.

However the backtest returned no trades, also even if the entire bar is printed below the plotted stop line, the long trade seems to continue so will not be able to use this stop line for SL orders me a bit confused on that ...

Anyway will ask the real questions only after spend some time on it...

Thanks for the efforts,

Rajadhiraj 16-06-2009 09:36 PM

http://img81.imageshack.us/img81/2958/kbrain.png

bimbo 16-06-2009 09:49 PM

Yes Raja u r Right.Even if the Bars cross the Sloss line it does not change the colors

Ajax i4u 16-06-2009 09:50 PM

http://img44.imageshack.us/img44/8798/ntpc.png

Just cursary look at the chart .. Prone to wipsaws
Please tell advantaes over other trend following systems.

karthikmarar 16-06-2009 11:35 PM

As I said in my blog... this is straight off the drawing board... :devilgrin:
It is not off the test bench.......... I want your inputs ... a collective response..
for improvements .. :) Then either we have a improved version or we trash it ..

karthikmarar 16-06-2009 11:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bimbo (Post 18972)
Yes Raja u r Right.Even if the Bars cross the Sloss line it does not change the colors

Don't look at just the colors.... It still kept in the trade... while most trailstop systems would have taken you out of the trade... :)

zerontgt 17-06-2009 10:54 AM

kbrain system Are you looking for 96% or 100%?
 
Hi friends,

Regarding the kbrain system, I am grateful to karthik for bringing things that exist in tradestation to amibroker.

Trading systems have a percentage probability of success.
If one says it did not change color even after it hit stoploss two times, it means you are aiming at a perfect system and that is not a reality.

when jimberg made his system on volatility and tested it it gave success rate of 65%.I know a lot of traders brokers included who bet and trade on this volatility system. One of the exit condition is exit as price hits stoploss line.
After experience now these traders use a modified condition exit only if price hits stoploss two times or more. Andf it works great.
These guys keep telling
It may loose 3 times, we dont care for small loss of 1 or 2 rupees but when it gives it gives a 30 or 50 rupees-and that is what we need.There is nothing perfect in trading systems.
Now if you want to know about volatility, think first are you ok with 65% success?
may be not hence forget it.
If someone here tells me of a 80% successful system, i will salute them.
Dont look a gift horse for minor flaws,instead think and apply your great ability and skill to use it best way possible-apply unconventional thinking process and you find a minor addition will change your outlook and results totally.
Are you looking for 100% perfection and in the process throw things that are better than 70%, and 80% and readily available at hand?
Well if there nothing much better than 70%,which is a reality,you will never trade as you wont reach your utopian goal.

Be realistic
be practical.

when you say this is only 70% success, and this is too bad, just think other way ,unlike many others which fail 40% or 50% of the time, this fails only 30%

When you say this not so good, and this has x y z flaws etc, just for a moment
CAN YOU POST YOUR EXISTING HIGH EFFICIENCY TRADING SYSTEM AND ITS DETAILS?
May be you wont.
becoz may be you got nothing out there

It is so easy to find a flaw and so difficult to appreciate.
let me not do the easy thing.

Rajadhiraj 17-06-2009 11:09 AM

hmm what was that about :duh:

Anyway ...

Hello Karthik

The trade signal becomes static only after completion of the bar, you may have to include this note somewhere.

The trade is executed at the close of the bar, taking the close as the executed price so no issues there, but for the person watching it live as the bar/candle is being printed the signal may appear as dynamic.

Thanks

zerontgt 17-06-2009 05:02 PM

Thanks to Mr Karthik
 
Hi Friends

It is so surprising and really something for a novice like me to feel better, to see Mr Karthik post a thanks here.
I still remember those days when we saw vsa stuff and were in confusion, and Mr Karthik came and gave his vpa afl thing that made life simple for Amibroker users including me. A great pleasure indeed!

I have used much of his stuff and keep thinking if I can make full use of the goodies he offered to guys like me-
I humbly salute his nature to offer
thought provoking stuff-we are grateful to him
Zerontgt
A learner-humbly-
cant repay the intellectual debt back to you in no possible way Mr karthik

karthikmarar 18-06-2009 03:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zerontgt (Post 19234)
Hi Friends

It is so surprising and really something for a novice like me to feel better, to see Mr Karthik post a thanks here.
I still remember those days when we saw vsa stuff and were in confusion, and Mr Karthik came and gave his vpa afl thing that made life simple for Amibroker users including me. A great pleasure indeed!

I have used much of his stuff and keep thinking if I can make full use of the goodies he offered to guys like me-
I humbly salute his nature to offer
thought provoking stuff-we are grateful to him
Zerontgt
A learner-humbly-
cant repay the intellectual debt back to you in no possible way Mr karthik

Thanks my Friend for the kind words. Just knowing that you find these useful itself makes worth those long hours spent on the computer… a computer dummy like me struggling with those funny codes… rather like rocket science for poor me.. Cutting, pasting … cursing at those strange error codes …tearing out my hair ..or.. rather .. whatever left of it… :hehe:

sandiip.sharma 18-06-2009 03:48 AM

Hi karthik, I always follow ur indicator.now this new Kbrain also got.can u add little more step in code for realtime scanning.Though we got scanned stock to enter.

zerontgt 18-06-2009 10:24 AM

k brain I used it and made money
 
HI GUYS
I have used k brain and made some money and without any stress or confusion becoz the entry exit stop are all in front of me on chart.
sincere Thanks karthik

Ajax i4u 18-06-2009 11:17 AM

http://img269.imageshack.us/img269/1562/nifty.png
:clap2::clap2:

Rajadhiraj 18-06-2009 07:32 PM

Hello

I plotted the KBrain on the chart I use to draw my swinging trading line, and the fun part was almost all the trades match with my afl, well almost but not all :hehe:

http://img14.imageshack.us/img14/985...mysandline.png

The two trades marked with red circle are the ones that gave me a wipsaw, but they were avoided by KBrain.

And its quite a coincidence that I started my Journal here on IT with these very trades marked by the red circle, all the other trades that followed are also duely recorded on the journal, talk of synchronicity :devilgrin:

Now that we have the code, it would be nice if Karthik you can throw-in some enlightenment about how it works, not really successful in doing anything other than changing colors and arrows on the afl

Thanks :risehat:

karthikmarar 20-06-2009 04:08 AM

Raja

In a nut shell the system basically uses the william % R to determine the Trend. WR above a certain value is considered uptrend and below a certain value as downtrend. The stop is ATR based. The concept is also used in ASC trend system.
Brain Trading system is a commercial package. Explanation of this commercial system concept is not available on the net. This work is based on Braintrend system clones basically done by Russian forex traders. Most interesting stuff on trading systems are found on Russian forums. They have done some great work on these. :risehat: to these guys.

regards

Rajadhiraj 20-06-2009 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by karthikmarar (Post 19994)
Raja

In a nut shell the system basically uses the william % R to determine the Trend. WR above a certain value is considered uptrend and below a certain value as downtrend. The stop is ATR based. The concept is also used in ASC trend system.
Brain Trading system is a commercial package. Explanation of this commercial system concept is not available on the net. This work is based on Braintrend system clones basically done by Russian forex traders. Most interesting stuff on trading systems are found on Russian forums. They have done some great work on these. :risehat: to these guys.

regards

Thanks :hail:

fjl24 28-07-2009 09:18 AM

Scan AFL For The MACD Indicator AFL
 
Dear Karthik

Firstly, A BIG THANKS for all the efforts and for sharing your research and findings with us all. "God Bless You Dear" :pray

In your - "A Guide To Technical Analysis - MACD" write up you made a specific mention about posting a scan afl for the MACD indicator that you have designed.:-?

Would sincerely appreciate if you could give us the links to those AFL or share it here on this thread.:hail:

Thanks in advance
Regards
Floyd:risehat:

fjl24 28-07-2009 09:25 AM

Hi Cas67

Thanks for starting this new thread. :clap2:

It is a tribute to Karthik for all his hardwork and sharing attitude.:hail:

I hope everyone is able to contribute and add value to the KBrain system designed by Karthik so as to give him our inputs and comments which will enable him to fine tune the system to the maximum extent possible.

Best Regards
Floyd:risehat:

callmemachoman 04-08-2009 06:52 PM

Hi Kartik,
.
Can we use two variation of paramters on KBrain one for taking position and one to book partial profit, because its a general rule after a big movement opposite trend is always week(80% ) times , what if you can add this variation.

karthikmarar 05-08-2009 02:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fjl24 (Post 28312)
Dear Karthik

Firstly, A BIG THANKS for all the efforts and for sharing your research and findings with us all. "God Bless You Dear" :pray

In your - "A Guide To Technical Analysis - MACD" write up you made a specific mention about posting a scan afl for the MACD indicator that you have designed.:-?

Would sincerely appreciate if you could give us the links to those AFL or share it here on this thread.:hail:

Thanks in advance
Regards
Floyd:risehat:

Dear Flyod

The scan is part of the Trading the MACD afl .

This can be downloaded from my 4shared folder..

http://www.4shared.com/dir/1136409/6...6/sharing.html

Regards

mmca2006 20-08-2009 08:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by karthikmarar (Post 19446)
Thanks my Friend for the kind words. Just knowing that you find these useful itself makes worth those long hours spent on the computer… a computer dummy like me struggling with those funny codes… rather like rocket science for poor me.. Cutting, pasting … cursing at those strange error codes …tearing out my hair ..or.. rather .. whatever left of it… :hehe:

Thanks karthik for spending your valuable time for small traders like us, really a great effort.
kindly guide me what period should I use for hourly chart for nifty? i.e Period 14 is fixed for all time frame or I should change it.I failed to back test it. Please guide.

tyagidk 23-08-2009 07:44 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Dear Mr. Karthik,
I have seen you many times coming up something great for small traders like me and be of great help.
I have some observations, some of which have already been raised by some friends:-
1. Please see tha attached banknifty chart, I am not getting the text on the chart stating trade entry point and profit etc so far in the current trade. What could be the reasons.
2. In backtesting, its not giving any trade. Please check whats worng with it?
3. If we change writeif function by alertif, we should be able to get the outputs in Alert Output window but its not doing so.

Please have a look at these minor points and clear if we people are making some mistakes.

Keep the good work going.

All the best.

Regarads

D. K. Tyagi

pakatil 23-08-2009 10:16 PM

@Tyagi,

Add this line at the start in the formula. Background becomes Black & every thing is visible.


SetChartBkColor(colorBlack) ;

faith 23-08-2009 10:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pakatil (Post 34609)
@Tyagi,

Add this line at the start in the formula. Background becomes Black & every thing is visible.


SetChartBkColor(colorBlack) ;

In amibroker>tools>preference>colour(select background colour black)

tyagidk 23-08-2009 11:36 PM

Thank you Mr. Faith and Mr. Pakatil, I could get the solution of my First query. But somehow, no one seems to be responding to Backtesting query and Alert Output query, raised by other friends also earlier, but has not fetched any response.:pray

karthikmarar 24-08-2009 01:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tyagidk (Post 34581)
Dear Mr. Karthik,
I have seen you many times coming up something great for small traders like me and be of great help.
I have some observations, some of which have already been raised by some friends:-
1. Please see tha attached banknifty chart, I am not getting the text on the chart stating trade entry point and profit etc so far in the current trade. What could be the reasons.
2. In backtesting, its not giving any trade. Please check whats worng with it?
3. If we change writeif function by alertif, we should be able to get the outputs in Alert Output window but its not doing so.

Please have a look at these minor points and clear if we people are making some mistakes.

Keep the good work going.

All the best.

Regarads

D. K. Tyagi

Dear Tyagi

You first query has been solved already. I will definitely look into the other two soon. I am currently tied up my work. I will reply on these at the earliest opportunity.

regards

mmca2006 24-08-2009 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tyagidk (Post 34581)
Dear Mr. Karthik,
I have seen you many times coming up something great for small traders like me and be of great help.
I have some observations, some of which have already been raised by some friends:-
1. Please see tha attached banknifty chart, I am not getting the text on the chart stating trade entry point and profit etc so far in the current trade. What could be the reasons.
2. In backtesting, its not giving any trade. Please check whats worng with it?
3. If we change writeif function by alertif, we should be able to get the outputs in Alert Output window but its not doing so.

Please have a look at these minor points and clear if we people are making some mistakes.

Keep the good work going.

All the best.

Regarads

D. K. Tyagi

Sir,
for backtesting just convert all conditions from 'NO" to "yes" in parameter option . Hope you will ge result. I also faced earlier same problem, now solved.

tyagidk 24-08-2009 02:34 PM

NO MMCA,
Its not happening. No backtest trade and no alert outputs.

lazytrader 24-08-2009 05:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by karthikmarar (Post 19994)
Raja

In a nut shell the system basically uses the william % R to determine the Trend. WR above a certain value is considered uptrend and below a certain value as downtrend. The stop is ATR based. The concept is also used in ASC trend system.
Brain Trading system is a commercial package. Explanation of this commercial system concept is not available on the net. This work is based on Braintrend system clones basically done by Russian forex traders. Most interesting stuff on trading systems are found on Russian forums. They have done some great work on these. :risehat: to these guys.

regards

Russian not just good at that, they are also the first to get into space, have the smartest scientists, hackers, crackers, virus writers, mathematicians. Some of the best aeronautical engineers, the best chess players and it doesn't stop there. if you have watched english movies you'll see russians are also well built and overall quite good mentally and phisically.

I think all this can be attributed to a secret traditional russian tonic. Although I don't want to give out the secret IT has good members so I'll tell you - its calls vodka. :devilgrin: Don't know if you guys know about it, big secret. :hehe: :))

mmca2006 27-08-2009 11:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by karthikmarar (Post 19028)
As I said in my blog... this is straight off the drawing board... :devilgrin:
It is not off the test bench.......... I want your inputs ... a collective response..
for improvements .. :) Then either we have a improved version or we trash it ..

Sir,
Please provide the AFL of BrainTrend2 , signal of Brain trend1 is to be supported by brain trend 2 . It is a very useful system with bain trend 2 .
Waiting for your reply. :-?

MiniTrader99 01-09-2009 10:31 PM

Dear Karthik Sir,
Thank you very much for pdg us K Brain system. Though I downloaded it long back started using it only recently. I found it very very useful because you are not out of trade just because of a bottoming tail. Last week it saved me thrice from reverting and in the end gave very good profit. Using it regularly. Even it recognised the trend change at early stage and you are in the position.As it is I dont find any shortcoming and consider it as a whole system. I think if support and resistance can be written in a box or shown in the chart it will be more useful.Thanks a lot for developing this AFL and sharing with us.


All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 08:27 AM.

iT
vB.Sponsors
vBulletin Copyright by vBulletin


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.3.2